Saturday, June 09, 2012

IHA Training Postscript

One of the great TC race performances goes down the tubes. What a shame! Congratulate Doug O'Neill for having  I'll Have Another absolutely primed for the Kentucky Derby, had a nice pre-Preakness training period where, instead of putting the horse under wraps as so many, O'Neill continued to vigorously train the horse, likely too much, and then, somewhere along the road, if u want to psychoanalyze the trainer and the methods, O'Neill literally lost his mind.

Here is a fellow that can talk to Billy Turner as to how Seattle Slew trained, comment on Lucien Lauren and the training of Secretariat, acknowledge Max Hirsch and Assault, and fail to get anything at all out of how those horses succeeded.

With O'Neill and his massive failure to understand performance and injury prevention, it went deeper than that.  Anybody that's been on a race track for any length of time knows that if you're going to two minute lick a horse every day you're going to injure that horse.  There was some Q in my mind since at Belmont they basically reserved the speed to just 4 fairly slow furlongs.  This is unknown territory to me and everybody else since nobody to my knowledge has ever beat on a horse this many consecutive days with a 150+ lbs rider on board around lengthy turns.  Maybe the horse's legs could take this since I am able to testify as to those stout stout Arch legs..  As it turns out, obviously otherwise.  And decline to swallow that "rapped himself" excuse since that just never happens. + by my recollect, the horse wears bandages.

My guess is that the injury is worse than advertised. How many horses have a trained with a little tendon puffiness one day and three days later they're back tight and back to training?  In the end I'll Have Another serves to remind that instead of training egg shells we're training egg yolk membranes.  The first part of wining the TC or any other race is to keep on the track healthy.  Somewhere O'Neill forgot that or perhaps has never understood Rule #1.

So, who will take the Belmont? Can they catch Paynter, who, with all due regard to the experts is hardly (look at him) a Bodemeister.  I'd think so. This should be a Dullahan runaway for a number of reasons. Rags has failed to do enough, failed to train at Belmont, has shown some laziness that he'll likely--if Matz can keep that horse healthy--need one more race to get back to form.  I think Rags will tie up short of the wire. Dullahan will be close to the pace and I see zero reason to bet against that good looking horse with the most appropriate training in this field

The rest of the field are throw outs with Street Life and Adonis having slight chances to break into the top three.  Barring unforseen developments those two simply lack the class of the top three.  Ditto rest of the field.  This is one where I'd try various tri-fecta, exacta combos.  I'm almost tempted to drive up to Des Moines and make a few bets I am so confident in the top three.  As always, will see.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Lazar Simic said...

There's no way that this type of injury is a "freakish thing" as O'Neill said.If you take a closer look at the horse when led by O'Neill at the last press conference the bow is clearly visible on that left front and from my experience this type of injury develops over a period of time,and once the problem started they tried to prevent it from getting worse with the shorter (up to one mile) gallops.So I 100% agree with you that it is not possible to go 2 min miles every day and still keep the horse sound,this type of workload is less likely to cause bone problems but soft tissues like tendons have a hard time to remain in good order.

6/9/12, 4:54 AM  
Anonymous Bill said...

Why must trainers make every gallop day the damn same? Why not 2min lick or faster 2-3x a week and use jogs/slow gallops in between to aid recovery?

The sudden shift from a month at rock-hard CD and fairly-hard PIM to the Big Sandy must contribute to soft tissue trauma - but that is what winning 3 long races over 3 different tracks in 5 weeks means.

He has the ultimate dilemma: train hard for fitness over a dramatically different surface and hope to remain sound, or train soft and go into the biggest race of his life short.

Glad I'm not a trainer.

6/9/12, 7:42 AM  
Anonymous Lazar Simic said...

What I don't like in his Belmont preparation is that he walked 3 days after the Preakness,then jogged another 2 or 3 days and then immediately started his Belmont one mile gallops with the strong last halves.Going from a walk/trot to almost high speed work over the different surface and the racecourse of the different design can cause the problem.Maybe he could start some slower galloping a bit earlier to allow some soft tissue adaptation and also,like you mentioned,2 min lick every other or every third day.This type of injury is always mentioned as an "overuse" injury, when you stretch hard these tendon fibers every day they don't have enough time to regenerate and eventually the lesion in the core of the tendon appears.2 min lick work is maybe not a big challenge for this horse cardiovascular system but his soft tissues in the lower legs can't adapt so quickly.

6/9/12, 9:14 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home